Weapon Brawl (series from EtG CI&A forum)

[OdinVanguard]

Weapon Brawl - EtG CI&A Board Link
Series dedicated to expanding the use of weapons (and shields) with an emphasis on "replacement" based effects.
A partial goal is to inspire a wider range of creatureless deck alternatives.

[timpa]

A lot of these feel better like spells. Some are plain OP. Needs some work imo.

[OdinVanguard]

Other than the generator (which should be good now) which ones are OP?

[timpa]

I'm not sure about the fan, I'd rather test it. White flag being OP as a permanent would depend on the change these cards bring to the meta.

I think white flag would be better as a spell (I said that in the thread already).

Thematically I'd have made the unstable runes a spell too.

Requip and Scrapyard seem fine and make a lot of sense as perms (both because of theme and dynamics).

I'm not sure if the current version of the generator is overnerf'd. I misunderstood it the first time too.