Ya, I kinda want something simpler to wield than the combo you show, but not as random as alchemist.
With this card, the spell card that is given back is randomly picked from the element of the discarded card, so there is still randomness, but at least you can control the element of the spell.
It doesn't have to be a permanent nor does it have to use aether or water, I just picked that because there was a cool theme that fit with it.
I think spell based decks could be a definite thing now, since we have enough counters finally (epoch, burn, yoink, silence, mirror shields etc.)